All-American
| Player | Year | Award |
| Andrew Metille | 2003 | Third Team |
| Fernando Diaz | 2001 | First Team |
| Mark Reynolds | 1993 | Honorable Mention |
| Scott Daugherty | 1986 | Honorable Mention |
Athletic All-Region
2018
| Player | Award |
| Pedro Nazario | Second Team |
| Raul Cosme | Honorable Mention |
| Oscar Rivera | Honorable Mention |
| Nathan Torres | Honorable Mention |
2017
| Player | Award |
| Pedro Nazario | Second Team |
| Victor Perez | Second Team |
| Ian Torres | Second Team |
| Erick Espinosa | Honorable Mention |
| Gabriel Leon | Honorable Mention |
| Stephan Soto | Honorable Mention |
2016
| Player | Award |
| Samuel Vega | Second Team |
| Bradly Lopez | Honorable Mention |
| Victor Perez | Honorable Mention |
2015
| Player | Award |
| Jason Roberts | Second Team |
| Ethan Westphal | Second Team |
| Erich Gonzalez | Honorable Mention |
| Angelo Rivera | Honorable Mention |
| Samuel Vega | Honorable Mention |
Academic All-Region
2018
| Player | Award |
| Isaac Esquilin | First Team |
| Daniel Hundley | First Team |
| Pedro Nazario | First Team |
| Jared Sekera | First Team |
| Stephan Soto | First Team |
| Dylan Torres | First Team |
| Ronnie Wigginton | First Team |
| Levi Avery | Second Team |
| Cade Cox | Second Team |
| Trevor Fisher | Second Team |
| Joanthony Hernandez | Second Team |
| Jose Mendez | Second Team |
| Jadriel Pantoja | Second Team |
| Gabriel Ramos | Second Team |
| Vincent Ramos | Second Team |
| Quentin Sefrit | Second Team |
2017
| Player | Award |
| Andre Beltran | First Team |
| Emilio Candelario | First Team |
| Jake Duren | First Team |
| Erick Espinosa | First Team |
| Gabriel Leon | First Team |
| Kenneth Negron | First Team |
| Victor Perez | First Team |
| Stephan Soto | First Team |
| Dylan Torres | First Team |
| Ian Torres | First Team |
| Kevin Torres | First Team |
| Rauvardo Torres | First Team |
| Marcus Chieves | Second Team |
| Waldemar Figueroa | Second Team |
| Manuel Hazoury | Second Team |
| Sean Houston | Second Team |
| Nick Houzenga | Second Team |
| Angel Morales | Second Team |
| Pedro Nazario | Second Team |
| John Poldberg | Second Team |
| Nathan Torres | Second Team |
2016
| Player | Award |
| 2016 Team - All-American | 19th Best GPA in NJCAA |
| Andre Beltran | First Team |
| John Bisignano | First Team |
| Sean Houston | First Team |
| Gabriel Leon | First Team |
| Bradly Lopez | First Team |
| Alex Madera | First Team |
| Kenneth Negron | First Team |
| Matt Olson | First Team |
| Kevin Torres | First Team |
| Rauvardo Torres | First Team |
| Brayann Ubiera | First Team |
| Gabriel Vazquez | First Team |
| Samuel Vega | First Team |
| Brian Anderson | Second Team |
| Drew Carlson | Second Team |
| Waldemar Figueroa | Second Team |
| Omar Frias | Second Team |
| Rickey Hernandez | Second Team |
| Joey Marcus | Second Team |
| Angel Morales | Second Team |
2015
| Player | Award |
| John Bisignano | First Team |
| Rafael Eigenmann | First Team |
| Omar Frias | First Team |
| Bradly Lopez | First Team |
| Angelo Rivera | First Team |
| Samuel Vega | First Team |
| Drew Carlson | Second Team |
| London Collins | Second Team |
| Misael Lebron | Second Team |
| Glenn Velazquez | Second Team |